Archived page: © 2001 Environmental Legal Information Systems (ELIS). All rights reserved. The information contained in this site is for demonstration and educational purposes, and while every effort has been made to simulate a potential real response to an oil spill, the storyline is not based on actual events. Developed by Kenneth J. Markowitz for the 2nd International Symposium on Digital Earth, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada (June 25, 2001). The external links on this page may no longer be functional.
|
Application of the Scenario Template
The text below guides users through the steps the development team took to create the Emergency Response Decision Information System Scenario. The developers followed the guidelines of the ELIS scenario template , developed as a tool to help ESIPs and other Digital Earth groups create stories illustrating potential actions or knowledge benefits derived from integrating Digital Earth data and images into their legal, environmental, educational, and media applications. Identify User Community and Its Needs The objective of the scenario is to demonstrate how the Digital Earth environment can improve the coordinated response efforts of multiple federal, state, and local agencies, contractors, and responsible parties under legal obligation to clean up the spill and protect public health and welfare. The scenario will enable the decision-maker to visualize a range of plausible outcomes based on available response assets, earth science data, and other relevant information. The scenario is designed to provide a tool for the user community to share information in real time to better coordinate response decisions and delegate responsibilities. Through the scenario, we hope to demonstrate the value of Earth Science Enterprise products and services, such as remote sensing satellite imagery, in leading to better response decisions. The User CommunityThe Emergency Response Decision Information System can be used by a range of stakeholders responding to or impacted by an oil spill. The potential user communities include government agencies, responsible parties, contractors, the public, and the media.This oil spill scenario is set in the Chesapeake Bay near Piney Point, Maryland in St. Mary's County. Below is a chart of some of the major participants in the emergency response activities. Because of the large number of agencies that would actually respond to an oil spill occurring in the Chesapeake Bay, all parties are not listed and examples of participants in each category are used instead.
User Community Needs
|
|
Identify
Relevant Data Sets and Providers
In this step of the scenario we also identify "indicators" that can be used to determine the best case response. Identifying the salient indicators is a crucial step in all types of problem solving, because the set of indicators simplify response by serving as solvable representatives of the problem. The main goal of oil spill clean-up and response is protection of economically and environmentally sensitive areas. It is critical for respondents to an oil spill to maintain and track a list of sensitivity indicators and have a current GIS map of relevant locations with as much information about the area as possible. Sensitivity Indicators for the Chesapeake Bay include:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Specify
Tools and Models to be Utilized
|
Simulate
Plausible Outcomes
After consideration of
all the above information, the final step of the scenario is to contemplate
the possible range of outcomes of an oil spill. While the US Coast Guard and
the EPA are experienced practitioners of oil spill cleanup, problems can arise.
For example, Lt. Jg. Knopf noted that there is a communication overloads in
the field when all the emergency response personnel use cellular devices and
Steve Jarvela discussed the problems that arise from not being to immediately
located response equipment. Unexpected difficulties such as these may cause
the worst-case scenario to occur: resulting in extensive long-term natural resource
damage. The best-case scenario, however, would result from the successful implementation
of the Emergency Response Decision Information System and result in minimal
and short-term environmental impact.
© 2001 Environmental Legal Information Systems (ELIS). All rights reserved. The information contained in this site is for demonstration and educational purposes, and while every effort has been made to simulate a potential real response to an oil spill, the storyline is not based on actual events.